Lies of P incorporates a lie mechanic which allows players to pick their responses and choose whether to tell the truth or tell a lie, resulting in different immediate rewards, outcomes, and even different endings.
Read ahead as we list down all of the choice dialogues in Lies of P and categorize them between lies and truths.
All Lies and Truths in Lies of P
The responses that you choose from during choice dialogues are often easy to know whether they are aligned with the truth or not, as long as they are usually contextualized by previous events or dialogues. However, it may get confusing which ones to choose as the story progresses, especially since the responses are not tagged as truths or lies. Additionally, lies aren’t necessarily tied to bad outcomes, just as truths are.
Listed below are the encounters where you will have to choose a truth or lie response, and their respective responses tagged accordingly as the truth or as a lie.
Location (Closest Stargazer) | NPC | Lie | Truth |
Inside the House on Elysion Boulevard | Weeping Woman | That's a cute baby | That's just a puppet |
St. Frangelico Cathedral Library | Alidoro | Venigni Works / Elysion Boulevard | Hotel Krat / Hotel Krat |
Rosa Isabelle Street Culvert | Julian the Gentleman | I saw the message she left, saying she loves you | I’ve never seen that happen before |
Hotel Krat (after defeating the King of Puppets in Ch.6) | Antonia | Of course | There's nothing left |
Hotel Krat (after defeating the King of Puppets in Ch.6) | Polendina | There's no such puppet | I have / |
Grand Exhibition Conference Room | Simon Manus | Monsters | Hope for a cure |
Hotel Krat (after defeating the Corrupted Parade Master in Ch.9 and accepting her side quest) | Belle | He was killed in battle | He’s become a monster |
Hotel Krat (after defeating the Black Rabbit Brotherhood in Ch.11) | Venigni | I couldn’t hear | Geppetto caused the Puppet Frenzy |
Hotel Krat (after deciphering Alidoro's Cryiptic Vessel) | Eugénie | I think he just was a talented Stalker | He was Eugénie’s older brother |
Arche Abbey Outer Wall | Arlecchino | Human | Puppet |
Ascension Bridge / | Sophia / | Give her peace / I gave her peace* | Let her live / I liberated her from Arche Abbey* |
Arche Abbey Upper Part | Geppetto | Yes | No |
*The action that you did with Sophia will determine which one of the two responses for Simon Manus will be the truth or a lie.
**This response will only show if you have obtained the Wedding Ring from completing Julian the Gentleman’s request.
Despite being a choice dialogue, the first encounter at the Hotel Krat door does not count towards determining the ending of the game.